Skip to main content
CompareHQ

How to Measure Training ROI

Most training is only ever measured by a same-day feedback form. This guide sets out what fuller measurement involves.

By Paige Thomson, Co-Founder. Published

Add CompareHQ as a preferred source on Google

On this page

Ask most organisations how they know their training worked, and for most the answer is a same-day feedback form asking whether people enjoyed the session. That measures satisfaction, not impact. Two established frameworks, Kirkpatrick and Phillips, set out what measuring impact looks like. Few organisations get that far, for reasons set out below.

Why ROI is rarely measured properly

Separating training's contribution to a business outcome from everything else happening at the same time (management changes, market conditions, seasonal variation) is hard. It also has to be planned before the training runs, not bolted on afterwards. A same-day feedback form is easy to collect. Tracking a job-performance metric three months later means deciding what to track in advance and then following up. That effort, more than any shortage of methodology, is why most measurement stops at satisfaction scores.

The Kirkpatrick Model

Introduced by Donald Kirkpatrick in 1959, this remains the most widely used framework for evaluating training, structured across four levels of increasing rigour and decreasing ease of measurement.

The four levels of the Kirkpatrick Model

Level

Level 1: Reaction

What it asks

Did participants find it engaging and relevant?

How it's typically measured

Same-day feedback form or survey

Level

Level 2: Learning

What it asks

Did knowledge or skill increase?

How it's typically measured

Pre/post assessment, skills test, demonstration

Level

Level 3: Behaviour

What it asks

Is it being applied back in the job?

How it's typically measured

Manager observation, follow-up survey, 90-day check-in

Level

Level 4: Results

What it asks

Did it move a real business outcome?

How it's typically measured

Performance data, error rates, retention, sales figures

The Phillips ROI Methodology

Jack Phillips extended Kirkpatrick's framework with a fifth level: Return on Investment, comparing the monetary value of a training programme's outcomes against its full cost, including design, delivery and participant time. You may see it claimed that “90-100% of training is evaluated at Level 1, but only 5-10% reaches Level 5”, presented as a measured industry statistic. That isn't quite accurate. Those figures are Phillips' own recommended allocation of evaluation effort (a guideline for where to focus resource-intensive ROI studies), not an audited measurement of what organisations do. A separate empirical survey, ASTD/i4cp's “Value of Evaluation” study (2009, 704 organisations), found real-world Level 5 usage closer to 16-18%. That is still a small minority, though noticeably higher than the commonly repeated “5-10%” figure. Both figures point the same way, since most organisations never reach a full ROI calculation, but cite the right one for the right claim.

Does leadership training work?

Setting evaluation models aside, the strongest evidence on whether leadership and management training works at all comes from two peer-reviewed meta-analyses, not vendor case studies. Lacerenza et al. (2017, Journal of Applied Psychology), pooling 335 independent samples, found leadership training produces measurable positive effects across reactions, learning, on-the-job behaviour and business results, and concluded that leadership training is “substantially more effective than previously thought.” The analysis also identified what improves results: a needs analysis beforehand, built-in feedback, multiple delivery methods with opportunities to practise, sessions spaced over time instead of a single one-off event, and face-to-face or on-site delivery over purely self-administered content.

An earlier meta-analysis, Collins & Holton (2004, Human Resource Development Quarterly), pooling 83 studies, reached a similar conclusion but added an important caveat: effect sizes were noticeably larger for knowledge gain than for on-the-job or organisational outcomes, and studies with weaker designs (no control group) tended to report bigger effects than more rigorous ones. Be sceptical, then, of any single training case study reporting a dramatic result.

Why skills often don't transfer to the job

A frequently repeated claim, that “only 10% of what's learned in training transfers to the job”, is not a research finding. It traces to a rhetorical, uncited remark in a 1982 trade article, later mistaken for a study result and repeated ever since. The published research on training transfer is more useful and less catchy. Baldwin & Ford's (1988, Personnel Psychology) foundational review identified three factors that determine whether skills stick: the trainee's own characteristics, how the training itself is designed, and the work environment they return to. Burke & Hutchins (2007, Human Resource Development Review) built on this, naming the work-environment factors that most affect transfer: whether someone gets the opportunity to use the new skill, manager support, peer support, and whether the organisation holds people accountable for applying it.

In practice, a provider can design a good session, but if there's no chance to practise the skill afterwards and no reinforcement from managers, the training is unlikely to stick, however well it was delivered on the day.

What to agree before training starts

Before the training runs

Practical measures beyond a feedback form

  • Pre- and post-training knowledge or skills assessment (Level 2)
  • Manager observation or a structured follow-up conversation 6-12 weeks later (Level 3)
  • 360-degree feedback comparing before and after, for behaviour-focused programmes
  • A specific business metric already being tracked: error rates, sales figures, retention, time-to-competence (Level 4)
  • A simple before/after comparison against a control group or a prior period, where possible

Calculating a basic ROI figure

At its simplest: (monetary value of the improvement, minus the full cost of the training) divided by the full cost of the training, expressed as a percentage. The arithmetic is rarely the hard part. Working out how much of the improvement is down to the training, and how much to other factors, is far harder. Where that can't be done reliably, it's more honest to report the behaviour change qualitatively than to force a precise ROI percentage that overstates certainty.

Common measurement mistakes

  • Only collecting same-day feedback and treating it as proof the training worked
  • Not deciding what to measure until after the training has already run
  • Attributing every change in a metric to training, ignoring other likely causes
  • Measuring immediately after training instead of allowing time for behaviour to change on the job
  • Forcing a Level 5 ROI figure onto training whose outcome can't be measured in monetary terms

Questions to ask providers

  • What evaluation do you build into your programmes, and at which Kirkpatrick level?
  • Can you share results, at Level 3 or 4, from a past client comparable to us?
  • How would you help us track behaviour change in the weeks after the session ends?
  • What would a Level 5 ROI evaluation look like for this programme, and is it realistic for us?

FAQs

What is the Kirkpatrick Model?

A four-level framework for evaluating training, introduced by Donald Kirkpatrick in 1959 and still the most widely used training evaluation model: Reaction, Learning, Behaviour and Results. Most organisations only measure Level 1, which tells you whether people enjoyed the session, not whether it worked.

What is the Phillips ROI Methodology?

An extension of the Kirkpatrick Model, developed by Jack Phillips, adding a fifth level: Return on Investment, comparing the monetary benefit of training against its full cost. Phillips' own guidance recommends that organisations reserve a full Level 5 ROI calculation for a small share of programmes, because separating training's financial impact from everything else going on in a business takes deliberate effort. In practice, a 2009 survey of 704 organisations put real-world Level 5 usage at around 16-18%.

Does leadership or management training work?

Peer-reviewed evidence says yes, on average. Two meta-analyses pooling hundreds of independent studies, Lacerenza et al. (2017) and Collins & Holton (2004), both found that leadership training produces measurable positive effects, though results-level outcomes are smaller and less consistently measured than reaction or learning-level ones. Provider testimonials and case studies don't count as this kind of evidence, since they're self-selected and rarely have a comparison group.

Why don't more organisations measure training ROI properly?

Separating training's contribution from other factors (market conditions, management changes, seasonal variation) is difficult, and doing it properly takes planning that has to start before the training runs, not after. It's easier to collect a same-day feedback form than to track a job-performance metric three months later, so most measurement stops at Level 1 by default, not by decision.

Can training ROI always be expressed as a number?

Not reliably for every type of training. Skills with a visible output (sales figures, error rates, production speed) are easier to measure than softer outcomes such as leadership judgement or team cohesion. For those, a mix of qualitative evidence (manager observation, 360 feedback) alongside any measurable proxy is usually more honest than forcing a single ROI percentage.

What should I measure if I can't do a full ROI calculation?

At minimum, agree a specific behaviour or metric you expect to change before the training starts, then check it again weeks or months later as well as on the day. That alone puts you ahead of measurement that stops at a same-day satisfaction score.

Sources and further reading

Choosing a provider who builds evaluation in from the start makes this whole process easier. CompareHQ's guide on how to choose a corporate training provider covers what to ask about measurement before you sign.

Compare corporate training providers

Compare verified UK corporate training providers by specialism, delivery format and price.

Compare providers